Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Society
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Five abuse reports, no protection: 3-year-old Osaka girl died before police were told

Hirakata city and the prefectural child guidance center logged a year of warnings about Erena Kanao. Neither took her into protective custody, and a plan to brief police in mid-August came after her death on August 3.

By Newsroom3 min read
Five abuse reports, no protection: 3-year-old Osaka girl died before police were told
Kentaro, left, and Elena (x)

A 3-year-old girl in Hirakata, Osaka Prefecture, died in August after her city received five reports of suspected abuse in about a year, and neither the city nor the prefectural child guidance center took her into protective custody, Shueisha Online reported.

Osaka Prefectural Police arrested her father, Kentaro Kanao, 33, a company employee, on suspicion of murder on November 13. Her mother, Riyo Kanao, 33, was arrested on suspicion of abandonment as a guardian causing death.

The reports came from sources including her nursery school, and included bruising seen on Erena's face. The city registered her as a child requiring protection in January.

No meeting with the mother this year

The city had not met the mother at all this year, the last meeting having been in December last year. When city officials confirmed bruising on Erena's face in July, they questioned only her father, who denied assaulting her.

Before her arrest, Riyo Kanao told prefectural police she had seen her husband hit their daughter's head on multiple occasions, according to reports.

Hirakata Mayor Takashi Fushimi posted on social media on November 14, the day after the arrests, that the city had received multiple reports since last year and had checked on the child and advised the parents.

He wrote that he would review the case with outside experts to establish what response was needed at each stage.

Information shared, but no intervention

The city shared information with the prefectural central child and family center, which runs the child guidance center, through a local council on measures for children requiring protection. It gave the center documents on the family's circumstances, the abuse reports and the guidance given to the parents.

Information was shared again at a June meeting. The city's first formal report to the center came on July 21, after the fifth abuse report.

At a news conference on November 16, the center said the case had been shared in January as one to be monitored jointly with the city. It said it decided with the city that no very high urgency existed, and that it never judged direct emergency action or protective custody necessary.

The center said it had not met Erena's parents face to face, and that it weighed the severity of the reports, the child's situation, the parents' situation and information from other agencies.

“We take it extremely seriously that this outcome occurred while the center had accepted the reports.”the prefectural central child and family center, news conference, November 16

A police briefing set for mid-August

On July 21, about two weeks before Erena died, the city summoned her father and gave him verbal guidance. The center knew of this but did not immediately pass it to prefectural police.

The center said it contacts police regularly and had planned to share the July report in mid-August. In very serious cases it informs police immediately, but it did not reach that judgment here.

Erena died on August 3, before the mid-August briefing. The center is preparing a system to share information with prefectural police in real time on similar cases regardless of the report's severity, starting next April.

On November 17, children's policy minister Nakatani called the case "a matter of the utmost regret" and said the government would notify municipalities nationwide to ensure proper protective custody and thorough information-sharing with police.

Mayor Fushimi told reporters on November 16 that communication between the agencies involved may have been too reserved, and that he wants the review of the administrative response completed by the end of March next year.