Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Society
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Japan's teacher vetting law has a blind spot: it cannot touch those already in the staffroom

A male teacher whose past sexual misconduct is widely known at his school still stands at the blackboard, and a vetting system starting next month would not have stopped him.

By Newsroom3 min read
Japan's teacher vetting law has a blind spot: it cannot touch those already in the staffroom
To what extent can Japan's version of the DBS protect children's sexuality? (x)

A male teacher at a Tokyo junior high school who once forced a woman into sex still works in the classroom, and the vetting system Japan introduces next month would not have caught him, Daily Shincho reported.

His conduct is recorded in detail on the internet. Students and parents at the school know about it, and the school has taken no action.

The case surfaced through a manga series, "Kyoiku Gyakutai" (Educational Abuse), running on the platform Bunch-kai. Its installment on sexual crime in schools drew a large response online.

The episode was based on a real teacher whose sexual trouble in his 20s was written up in detail on a bulletin board. The school could not discipline him, and he carried on working as if nothing had happened.

Two incidents, no punishment

The teacher had two incidents behind him. In the first, at the end of his teens, he took an elementary school child into a toilet and molested the child.

He was a minor at the time, so the case ended with probation and his name was not reported. All that remained were anonymous posts on a bulletin board.

A female teacher at a public junior high school who helped with the manga's research said such posts spread through a school within moments.

“Even if the person admits it, it is effectively impossible to dismiss him or push him into retiring, because it is a thing of the past.”the teacher told the magazine, public junior high school teacher

A school can move a teacher to another school early when a case becomes too big. But the rumor follows, and the teacher is passed from school to board of education office as a "teacher to watch."

The second incident was messier. One night the teacher drove an elementary school girl around in his car until late at night.

Parents and the school feared a kidnapping. When he brought her back, he said the girl had trouble at home and did not want to return, so he had listened to her in his car without telling her parents.

The girl stayed silent, tense. Her parent was furious and said he would go to the police. In the end the two sides settled, with money paid.

The parent was known for bad behavior and was satisfied with a luxury car bought with the settlement money, the magazine reported. Other parents were not satisfied.

Why the school cannot act

Even with a suspicious act, a settlement between the parties is a contract of reconciliation. A school, as a third party, cannot easily dig it up or hand down a punishment.

“If it does that and cannot prove wrongdoing, it could be sued in return.”the teacher said, public junior high school teacher

A public elementary school principal is transferred every three or four years, and other teachers are busy with their own work. Teachers are not journalists or lawyers, so they cannot investigate and judge.

Facts stay vague, and the teacher keeps standing at the blackboard. In this case the girl kept silent and her parent settled for money.

Getting the girl to testify would risk tearing open a wound. That is too much for one teacher to do alone.

The blind spot in the Japanese DBS

Japan's version of the DBS, modeled on Britain's Disclosure and Barring Service, is due to reach schools in December 2026. It lets employers check the sexual crime records of people who work with children through a national database.

A record allows a school to reassign the teacher, restrict his duties or urge him to resign. But the database only carries cases that went to prosecution and ended in a guilty verdict.

A prison term, a suspended sentence or a fine puts a person in the database. A settlement does not.

“What worries me is that most sexual crimes against children are probably never prosecuted.”the teacher said, public junior high school teacher

Only a small share of child pornography cases end in prosecution and conviction, and other sexual violence is likely similar, she said.

Under that logic, the DBS catches only clumsy offenders who slip up. Cunning ones may stay free.

A Ministry of Education survey counted 281 public school teachers who faced disciplinary action in fiscal 2024 for sexual crimes or sexual violence, including possession of child pornography.

That is out of more than 800,000 teachers at public schools. Anyone can imagine it is the tip of an iceberg.