Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Society
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Nursery staff ask what more they could have done for slain 3-year-old in Hirakata

A former caregiver at Erena Kanao's preschool says the staff have been questioning themselves constantly since the girl's death, as Osaka Prefecture and Hirakata city move to review how five abuse reports failed to save her.

By Newsroom2 min read
Nursery staff ask what more they could have done for slain 3-year-old in Hirakata
The apartment building where suspect Kentaro Kanao and others lived at the time of the incident, in Hirakata, Osaka Prefecture, at 3:13 p.m. on October 13, 2026. (x)

A staff member at the preschool Erena Kanao once attended said the center has been constantly asking itself what more it could have done, after the 3-year-old was beaten to death in Hirakata, Osaka Prefecture, and her parents arrested.

The staff member told the Mainichi Shimbun on Saturday, "It hurts my heart. I am always asking myself whether there was more we could have done."

Erena died in August in an apartment in Hirakata after being punched repeatedly and subjected to other violence. Her father, Kentaro Kanao, 33, was arrested by Osaka prefectural police on suspicion of murder. Her mother, Riyo Kanao, 33, was arrested on suspicion of abandoning a person under her care, causing death.

Kindergartens and nurseries contacted the city with suspicions of abuse five times over about a year, according to what has emerged about the case.

The staff member declined to say whether the preschool had filed a report, or to describe how Erena seemed at the time, citing privacy. The staff member recalled hearing before the case was reported that Erena had died, but not knowing why, and assuming it might have been an accident.

The staff member learned it was a crime from news that both parents had been arrested. "I believe every child has a bright future. And yet it turned out like this, and it is truly painful," the staff member said. "We supported her as much as we could, but it is such a shame and it hurts my heart."

Reviews at city and prefecture level

The city has said it will review how it handled the case. It has also emerged that a child consultation center knew of the situation but did not take Erena into temporary protective custody. Osaka Governor Hirofumi Yoshimura has said he will set up a review panel of experts.

The staff member said much remains unknown and called on the city and prefecture to investigate thoroughly and share the results. "On that basis, we want to think about what the preschool could have done," the staff member said.