Two samples of Chinese-made sucralose sold in Japan contained an impurity flagged as DNA-damaging at 40ppm and 90ppm, well above the 20ppm yardstick a food-additive expert uses for human safety, yet shoppers cannot see the sweetener's origin or the risk on a label.
Sucralose, roughly 600 times sweeter than sugar, is a fixture of processed breads, snacks and soft drinks sold in supermarkets and convenience stores. So are acesulfame potassium and aspartame. All three cost less than sugar and keep flavor consistent, which makes them close to essential for major food and beverage makers.
Japan imports artificial sweeteners mainly from Europe, the United States, China and Southeast Asia. Daily Shincho sent questionnaires to 32 major manufacturers of soft drinks, bread and processed foods to ask which sweeteners they use and how they are made.
The impurity
A 2023 paper by researchers at North Carolina State University and elsewhere reported that sucralose-6-acetate, an impurity formed during the manufacture of sucralose, is genotoxic. Genotoxicity is the capacity to damage DNA, the genetic information in cells. Damaged DNA that is not repaired can alter how a cell behaves and, in the worst case, lead to cancer.
Experts continue to argue over the finding. At a minimum, the risk that sucralose harms the human body has not been ruled out.
Mikio Nakamura, a doctor of pharmacy who has served on the health ministry's committee drafting the official compendium of food additives and on the Consumer Affairs Agency's food labeling panel, said the impurity has been found in sweetener circulating in Japan.
“Sucralose-6-acetate is being detected in large quantities in Chinese-made sucralose actually distributed in Japan.”Mikio Nakamura, doctor of pharmacy
At a study meeting held at the House of Councillors members' office building in June 2025, the nonprofit Japan Family Farmers Movement's food analysis center reported finding the impurity at 40ppm and 90ppm in two samples of Chinese sucralose, he said. Against a 20ppm yardstick for human safety, those figures are two and 4.5 times the level.
Why fewer steps
Sucralose is built through a complex series of chemical reactions, and impurities arise along the way. To cut production costs, some plants have shortened the traditional six-step process to a four-step method, simplifying purification so that impurities of concern for genotoxicity are not removed, Nakamura said.
He said he has heard from people in the chemical industry that sucralose is made in China by the four-step method. Research on a three-step method is also under way there, he said.
The concern has come up repeatedly in the Diet. In May, an opposition lawmaker questioned the Consumer Affairs Agency at the upper house agriculture committee about impurities in Chinese artificial sweeteners. A bureaucrat answering said standards exist and are enforced, so there is no food-safety problem.
Nakamura rejected that. Japan approved sucralose in 1999, and he was the official responsible for drafting the application. He also drew up the standards, at a time when genotoxicity from sucralose impurities was not a concern and did not cross anyone's mind, he said.
“If new research points to a problem, you verify again in light of that knowledge. Isn't that the role of an administration protecting food safety?”Mikio Nakamura
A food additive may be sold once it meets the standards the state has set, he said. An impurity that only later becomes a concern may therefore not be subject to testing. That makes the stance of the companies using the ingredient important, he said.
Daily Shincho's survey asked the 32 manufacturers about their use of Chinese artificial sweeteners and the production method behind the sucralose they buy. A named list of their responses is published on the outlet's Shinsho QUE platform, alongside other health risks found in Chinese artificial sweeteners.
