Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Society
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Five Reports to a City, Two Dead 3-Year-Olds: Japan's Child-Protection Gaps Under Scrutiny

Hirakata logged five abuse reports before Erena died. In Itami, a nursery worker's warning never reached the child consultation center. ABC News asked why neither case was stopped.

By Newsroom3 min read
Five Reports to a City, Two Dead 3-Year-Olds: Japan's Child-Protection Gaps Under Scrutiny
Suspect Shinya Arimoto, 29 (x)

Two 3-year-old girls died in Osaka and Hyogo prefectures and their parents were arrested, and in the Osaka case the city had received five reports about the child before she died, ABC News reported.

Itami: a warning that never reached the consultation center

In Itami, Hyogo Prefecture, Ranon Arimoto, 3, died and her father, Shinya Arimoto, 29, was arrested and sent to prosecutors on suspicion of assault causing death. He denies the charge, saying "it is not true."

Before his arrest, Arimoto told police in substance that the girl had lost consciousness while he was not watching, and that he did not know why she died.

According to Hyogo Prefecture, Ranon had told staff at a child welfare facility where she had previously lived that "Papa is scary" and that he "does pechin" — a child's word for smacking. The exchange was not shared with the child consultation center at the time, and the prefecture did not know about it.

Between September and the end of December last year, while Ranon was staying at home, her mother reported about 10 "minor injuries" to the child consultation center. A log recorded entries such as "tripped and hit her chin."

Staff confirmed the injuries and concluded there was "nothing to suggest abuse," partly because Arimoto and the others complied with guidance on preventing injuries.

Hirakata: five reports, and a video on a phone

In Hirakata, Osaka Prefecture, Erena Kanao, 3, died. Her father, Kentaro Kanao, was arrested on suspicion of assault and murder. Investigators found video on his smartphone of him punching and slamming the girl, according to people involved in the investigation.

A camera had been set up in the room and captured him hitting and striking her. Stair climbing described as "training" was taking place there, and he is believed to have transferred footage to his phone to monitor it.

His wife, Riyo Kanao, 33, was arrested on suspicion of abandoning a person under her care, causing death. Before her arrest she told police in substance that she might have prevented it if she had stopped her husband's violence.

She had sometimes warned him not to hit the girl hard enough to leave bruises, and police suspect the violence was a daily occurrence.

Why five reports did not stop it

Hirakata received five reports before Erena died. In July, when the last report came in, bruises were confirmed on her face and body, and the city formally notified the child consultation center.

ABC News reporter Nakamoto said the city was in a difficult position. City rules require a visit once a report is received, and the city sought a meeting every time, but there were occasions when it could see Erena and occasions when it could not.

“With privacy to consider, the city could not intervene strongly in the family. I think it was in a difficult position.”Nakamoto, ABC News reporter

Child consultation centers hold powers of intervention. Cities do not have that level of coercive authority.

The city said at a press conference that it had judged "no emergency response was necessary." Nakamoto suggested abuse may have escalated sharply after that point.

How Osaka Prefecture shares abuse cases

When Osaka Prefecture's child consultation centers receive a suspected-abuse report from a municipality or other body, they share it immediately with police if the case is judged high-risk with a threat to life. All other cases are bundled into a month's worth and shared the following month.

The Hirakata case fell into the second category. A new "real-time sharing" system between cities and police had been scheduled for introduction next April.

“If this case too could have been watched by the two eyes of the child consultation center and the police, it might have been prevented.”Nakamoto, ABC News reporter

Caseloads up sevenfold in 20 years

Cases handled by child consultation centers rose from 33,408 in fiscal 2004 to 223,691 in fiscal 2024, roughly seven times as many, according to the Children and Families Agency.

Staff workloads are severe. Hirakata has about 20 counselors handling abuse cases, each responsible for about 80, according to Nakamoto. The national standard treats 40 per person as already a substantial load, so each carries nearly double that.

“The state is increasing the number of child consultation centers and staff, but a lack of experience has become the challenge. In the Hirakata and Itami cases, there may have been problems in gathering and sharing information to judge abuse risk, and in how they responded.”Fumiharu Yamagata, specially appointed professor at Osaka Junior College of Early Childhood Education

The Children and Families Agency said it will carry out an emergency nationwide inspection of how child consultation centers and municipalities coordinate.