Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Politics
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Komeito lawmaker and defense minister trade blows over "merchants of death" jibe

Yamane Taku stands by his Diet criticism of arms exports; Koizumi Shinjiro asks whether he would say it to defense workers' faces.

By Newsroom3 min read
Komeito lawmaker and defense minister trade blows over "merchants of death" jibe
Communist Party policy chief Takashi Yamazoe at a press conference in the Diet building on the afternoon of November 13. (x)

A Communist Party policy chief and the defense minister are still arguing on X over whether Japan has become a "merchants of death" state, after a Diet clash over Japanese support for US weapons production spilled into public view.

Yamane Taku, the party's policy committee chair, used the phrase during a House of Councillors Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee session on the 12th. He argued that Japan was replenishing munitions consumed in large quantities in the US attack on Iran.

Backing the growth of the arms industry while sustaining an illegal war, he said, meant the country could only be called a "merchants of death" state.

Koizumi's counterattack

Defense Minister Koizumi Shinjiro pushed back in the same session. "There was baseless criticism. I cannot say such a thing in front of the people who work in the defense industry. Can you?" he asked.

That night the Defense Ministry and the Self-Defense Forces posted a message from Koizumi to defense industry employees on their official X account. "I think there was a time when thoughtless words were thrown at you and you felt you had no place to stand," he said.

He added: "We defend our own country ourselves. With that resolve, we will strengthen the defense industrial base. The state will take the lead." A separate post said their work "is what actually creates the power that protects Japan," calling defense industry workers "Japan's treasure."

Yamane: I was criticizing national policy

Yamane answered on his own X account on the 12th. Koizumi's answers, he wrote, "do not answer what is asked, and not only shift the debate but attempt a counterattack — that is how it always is."

On the 13th he quoted the ministry's post and said the government was pushing a doubling of military spending and an expansion of weapons exports. "This is not something that can be tidied up with words like defending our own country ourselves," he wrote.

At a news conference on the 13th, Yamane said the phrase targeted national policy, not defense industry employees. He had criticized "the national policy of being a merchants of death state that supports the arms industry," he said.

Some workers, he said, "take pride in manufacturing the equipment needed for the long-standing exclusively defense-oriented policy and for disaster relief." He also pointed to the government's move to acquire counterstrike capability and export weapons with lethal capacity. "It is all being done as national policy, so of course it should be criticized in any setting," he said.

“I want to criticize the merchants of death state even in front of the people working in the defense industry.”Yamane Taku, Communist Party policy committee chair

He added that it was Koizumi who should be asked whether he could tell workers to their faces that they were supporting an illegal war.

A third voice

Shinba Kazuya, secretary-general of the Democratic Party for the People, told a news conference on the 13th that the exchange "was not a particularly high-level debate." He recalled that when he once rebutted a politician who had called defense equipment "tools for killing people," a defense industry employee thanked him in tears.

Shinba said children who wonder whether their father is making tools to kill people are left with nowhere to turn. "It is fine to oppose nuclear power plants. But there are people working desperately in them," he said. "I want you to speak with care for those people."