Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Politics
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Defense Ministry blames shell for tank explosion that killed 3; no company liability found

A rubber component that burned onto a shell set off the blast inside a Type 10 tank at the Hijudai training ground, the ministry concluded, and the Self-Defense Forces will resume firing with a different shell type.

By Newsroom2 min read
Defense Ministry blames shell for tank explosion that killed 3; no company liability found
Rubber components wrapped around a shell. After the accident, part of an identical item was found partially unburned. Asahi Shimbun (x)

Japan's Defense Ministry said the shell itself caused the explosion that killed three soldiers and injured a fourth inside a tank at the Hijudai training ground in Oita Prefecture, and it will not hold the manufacturer responsible.

The ministry announced the findings on the 19th. Live-firing drills that were suspended will resume in stages using a different type of shell, the Asahi Shimbun reported.

The accident happened on the morning of April 21. A shell detonated inside a Type 10 tank during a firing drill, killing the tank commander, 45, the gunner, 31, and a safety officer, 30, who were in the turret above the hull. The driver, inside the hull, was seriously injured.

How the blast happened

The detonation occurred between shots. As the tank fired its third shell, a rubber component wrapped around the shell slipped inside the barrel and burned, leaving a residue behind.

The tank loads shells into the barrel automatically. The residue stopped the fourth shell from seating fully, so the breech — the lid separating the barrel from the turret where the four men were — did not close completely.

Paint had peeled from part of the fourth shell, leaving it hot. It touched the heated residue and ignited about 15 seconds later, and the blast blew back into the turret, the ministry concluded.

The shell met the standards the ministry sets, and holding the manufacturer responsible would be difficult, the ministry said. It will develop and procure ammunition whose components are less likely to burn, and will keep the same shell type out of use for now.

Earlier cases went unreported

Components had burned and left breeches unable to close twice before at the Ground Self-Defense Force's Fuji School in Oyama, Shizuoka Prefecture. Neither case was reported to the Ground Staff Office, the ministry said, and it will require full reporting from now on.

"We will do everything to ensure the safety of our members so that this kind of accident never happens again," Ground Self-Defense Force Chief of Staff Masayoshi Arai said at a news conference on the 19th.

Training constrained

The force cannot fire the shell that detonated for now and must train with a different type. With ammunition already said to be in short supply, some see a lasting effect on Japan's defense strategy, and troops at the ground have voiced unease. "I'm scared to ride in a tank," one said.