Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Politics
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Japan's internal affairs ministry weighs legal basis for site blocking

A ministry panel opened talks on forcing telecoms to cut access to leaked personal data, a step that could test constitutional protections for communications secrecy.

By Newsroom1 min read

The internal affairs ministry opened a panel of experts on Friday to weigh how to stop the spread of personal data leaked in cyberattacks, including whether forcing telecoms to block sites would need new legislation.

The first meeting of the panel will sort out the legal standing of blocking, under which carriers check every destination a user connects to and refuse access to the targeted site regardless of the user's wishes. The Mainichi Shimbun reported that the talks will keep the possibility of future legislation in view.

Blocking risks infringing on the secrecy of communications and the freedom to know and express, both guaranteed by the Constitution. Debate over illegal online casinos avoided a judgment on the measure for that reason.

GMO Internet leak prompted government request

In the unauthorized access case at GMO Internet Group, the government asked telecom carriers to block sites carrying personal data said to belong to customers. In its materials for the meeting, the panel's secretariat wrote again that "implementation requires some form of legal basis." It asked members to discuss desirable procedural requirements and the process, including the possibility of legislation in the future.

Other ways to curb access include filtering, which restricts connections to a site, and domain suspension, which makes a domain — an address on the internet — unusable. Each has drawbacks: filtering requires the user's consent, and measures against overseas sites are difficult. The panel will also discuss how effective these steps are.

Members voice caution

Members raised cautious views at the meeting. One said blocking "has big side effects, but is not as effective as people generally think."