The government has floated an annual payment of about ¥5,000 for people earning ¥1.19 million or less, to accompany a consumption tax cut in fiscal 2027, and the figure has drawn ridicule from the public, ABEMA Times reported.
The payment is meant to offset the 1% of consumption tax that still applies to food, a levy the government wants to scrap but cannot fully remove at the register. The total pot is roughly ¥600 billion.
Spread across the population, that works out to about ¥5,000 per person per year. For the lowest earners the minimum payment is set at around ¥5,000 a year, or about ¥417 a month and ¥13 a day.
Scorn online and on the street
Reaction on social media was blunt. "What are they thinking, ¥5,000 a year?" one post read. Another asked: "Will ¥5,000 a year make life stable?" A third said: "What does the government want to do with a ¥417 monthly payment? Does this amount even need to exist? It's not a child's allowance."
People interviewed on the street were no warmer. A man in his 50s said the sum had little meaning. "You can only laugh," he said. "The paperwork will cost more than the payment."
A couple in their 30s said the amount was too small to serve as pocket money, and that ¥5,000 a month, or ¥60,000 a year, might be reasonable.
Kataoka defends the plan in the Diet
Prime Minister Sanae Kataoka defended the plan in the lower house finance committee on the 6th. "The overall picture of the funding, in other words the amount, is decided," she said. "We will make it clear during the year-end budget compilation process while listening to a wide range of views."
On who would qualify, she said the share of working recipients would be "at least around 30%, comparable to other countries."
A policy meant to show concern for the poor
Yukari Ito, deputy editor of the election site Go2senkyo, told the program that the public's complaint about the size of the payment is "entirely correct." She read the policy as a signal that the government is looking after low earners affected by the tax cut.
Naoko Sawai of TV Asahi's political desk said the original purpose may not be reaching the public. The pledge was to zero the consumption tax on food, she said, but register systems allow only a 1-point cut. The government therefore plans to pay back the 1% over two years, about ¥600 billion in total.
Kataoka has repeatedly said she will "explain thoroughly," but has only indicated the details will be settled with the year-end budget. Sawai said the plan is probably not yet fixed, which is why it is hard to follow.
The ¥5,000 is not a flat sum, Sawai said. It scales with income, and people earning ¥2 million to ¥3 million should receive more. Where the cutoff falls is unclear, she said, with talk that payments stop around ¥3.5 million, though Kataoka has suggested a higher ceiling in the Diet.
Sawai also said the government has dribbled out the scope of the program. The "roughly 30%" figure would mean about 20 million of Japan's 70 million working people, she said, adding that the plan is genuinely hard to understand.
Ito said too much remains undecided, and that shifting social conditions make the funding hard to pin down. She predicted a delayed public reckoning. "If they don't explain in a way that eases anxiety about the money up front, pushback will come eventually," she said.