Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Politics
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Four LDP abstentions expose cracks in Takaichi's one-strong grip

A party that spent a year warning against unfunded tax cuts reversed itself, and four veterans sat out the vote. President Online reports the unease inside the LDP.

By Newsroom4 min read

Four Liberal Democratic Party lawmakers left the chamber rather than back a consumption tax cut the party had spent a year warning against, and the revolt has left the party nervous, President Online reported.

The consumption tax cut bill began Upper House debate on the 11th. In the Lower House plenary vote, four lawmakers withdrew just before the ballot.

They were former Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, former election strategy chief Yuko Obuchi, former Economic Planning Agency chief Hajime Funada and former justice minister Yoshihisa Furukawa.

Former LDP Secretary-General Hiroshi Moriyama, a veteran of the party's tax panel, criticized the bill at a policy study meeting in Tokyo's Uchisaiwaicho district the same day.

“For a year until last year the LDP kept saying an unfunded consumption tax cut must never happen. Tax policy that flips around in a year has to be handled with restraint.”Hiroshi Moriyama, former LDP secretary-general

Moriyama voted for the bill in the plenary session. He nonetheless voiced sympathy for the four, saying debate on what happens without funding was thin.

“It is hard to speak up after the prime minister's landslide in the Lower House election. But the four's action may reflect how people feel.”Hiroshi Moriyama

Moriyama himself once rebelled against the party, left it and later returned. He opposed postal privatization under Junichiro Koizumi and won as an independent before rejoining.

Ishiba was close to the four. Obuchi formerly led the party's election strategy and remains close to the faction her father, former Prime Minister Keizo Obuchi, once led.

Funada and Furukawa both belonged to the same faction, the Heisei Research Council.

A show of strength in the numbers

On the same day, a caucus of LDP lawmakers supporting Takaichi met at the Diet. The Group for National Strength drew 129 members, including Deputy President Taro Aso and acting Secretary-General Koichi Hagiuda.

It was the group's second meeting, after a first in May. Chairman Katsunobu Kato, a former finance minister, said it would back the prime minister and answer the expectations of the last Lower House election.

Defense Minister Shinjiro Koizumi urged strong support for the government. Policy Research Council chief Takayuki Kobayashi, Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi and former internal affairs minister Masayoshi Hayashi, all rivals in last year's leadership race, also joined.

One young LDP lawmaker described the mood in the party.

“While the cabinet's approval rating stays high, it is hard to move. I think the tax cut is a bad move, but if you badmouth the prime minister back home you get scolded. Everyone thinks staying quiet is the smart play.”an LDP lawmaker

The same lawmaker said the rebels were veterans with safe seats, and that rank-and-file members fear the leadership's displeasure.

Approval holds, but for how long

Cabinet approval ratings have held roughly steady across broadcasters, from 64.9 percent in JNN's survey to 42.4 percent in Jiji Press's. NHK's latest put support at 53 percent, up 2 points.

All the pollsters show support 15 to 20 points below where it stood a year ago. A former LDP official who knows the party well disputed the idea of a rock-solid conservative base.

“There is no bedrock conservative layer. The opposition is fragmented and self-destructing, so people who once backed the LDP are joined by those thinking the LDP is fine.”a former LDP official

The official said the top reason given for support in surveys is that no one else is better. A Yomiuri Shimbun poll a year ago had policy expectations first at 41 percent and no better alternative at 20 percent.

In the October survey, no better alternative led at 32 percent, overtaking policy expectations at 22 percent.

Upper House LDP officials say the punishment for the four was too light to deter others. The party still lacks a majority in the chamber, where a revolt could sink a bill.

The four raised questions that remain unanswered: whether the 10 trillion yen funding gap the cut opens over two years can be filled, whether it helps against prices, and whether markets will trust it.

Opposition parties have taken up the same questions. The Democratic Party for the People and Komeito, both open to backing the bill with amendments, are raising their demands.

Ishiba is said to be staking his political life on the fight. People close to him say he feels self-loathing for having backed the imperial household law revision and a bill on flag desecration.

An associate of Obuchi said she was asked to resign as vice chair of the party tax panel and told them to cut her down instead.

Asked whether the four would feed into next year's leadership race, Moriyama was noncommittal.

“I don't know who will run, but I hope it is a lively race.”Hiroshi Moriyama