Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Politics
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

LDP disciplines four lawmakers who abstained on food tax cut bill

The bill cutting the food consumption tax to 1% reached the Upper House on Wednesday, after four LDP members sat out the Lower House vote and were reprimanded.

By Newsroom3 min read

The LDP has reprimanded four of its lawmakers, including former Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, for abstaining on a bill cutting the consumption tax on food to 1%, as debate on the bill began in the House of Councillors on Wednesday.

The bill would cut the rate on food to 1% and pay the equivalent of that 1% to low-income households as a support benefit. The abstentions came in the Lower House vote that preceded the Upper House session.

The party also removed Yuko Obuchi, a former economy, trade and industry minister, from her post within the LDP's tax research commission. The four members were disciplined with a reprimand — a formal warning from the party leadership — for defying the party whip.

The four acted over the bill's funding. Ishiba said the government had answered that there was "no need to worry" about replacement revenue, but that what that revenue would be "is still not clear." Obuchi said her concerns, starting with the funding, had not been dispelled.

Upper House scrutiny opens

At the start of questioning in the Upper House, Komeito's Takaharu Satomi called the bill one that asks the Diet for a blank check. He said it was "a blot on constitutional history" and "the arrogance of a government that belittles the legislature."

Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi replied that the requirements for the benefit payments would be set by cabinet order. She said this would allow flexible responses to changes in social conditions, including revisions to tax and social insurance systems and international comparisons.

Shinichi Shiba of the Constitutional Democratic Party asked whether the permanent funding source would include tax increases. Takaichi avoided a direct answer, saying her government would secure the revenue by curbing subsidies and tax breaks rather than relying on special deficit-covering bonds.

Sanseito secretary-general Hiroshi Ando said the prime minister had called the two-year food tax cut her long-held goal. He argued the Upper House could not finish in the one hour the Lower House took, especially after four LDP members abstained there.

Takaichi said she had attended and answered sincerely whenever the Diet requested her presence, during the Lower House debate on the bill and in the Upper House.

A divided party

Speaking on ABEMA's news program, Naoko Sawai, the Asahi TV political desk's ruling-party chief, said the party leadership had spent months trying to bring the tax commission along. It held repeated meetings of party panels and tax commission executives from around July, when Obuchi resigned from the commission's inner circle.

Sawai said opposition to the cut and support for fiscal reconstruction remain deeply rooted in the LDP. When the party settled on backing the cut, it imposed the whip — the binding instruction to vote with the party — but discussion was constrained because the party's internal debate was relayed to the Prime Minister's Office. Three or four in ten tax commission members were cautious, she said, and among its executives almost all were.

Yukari Ito, deputy editor of election site Senkyo.com, said the four appeared to have made a heavy decision. She said they did not act together and each had their own reason for leaving the chamber, and that the bill's supporters were not split.

Sawai said some in the party fear the swift reprimand could unite anti-Takaichi forces. She said the speed came from Takaichi's wish to act early.

Ito said the opposition is pressing the same funding question. Repeating the same answers gives the impression that the explanation has not been made, she said. She added that politicians and voters alike face hard judgments when conditions change after an election.

Sawai said the policy itself is loosely designed. The funding has not been shown, and who receives the benefit and how much remain unknown. The four abstainers' arguments are close to the opposition's: the funding is unclear, and cash benefits may be better than a tax cut.

A tax cut benefits wealthier households most, because they buy more food, Sawai said. Benefits, by contrast, can go toward what a household needs, such as school supplies.