The Defense Ministry has asked for close to ¥80tn for the five years from next fiscal year, while the government has floated a plan anchored around ¥50tn, and Liberal Democratic Party lawmakers pushed back at a meeting on the 18th.
The meeting was held as the party works toward revising the three security documents by the end of the year. Defense spending dominated it, according to reports.
Under the government proposal, defense spending for the five years from fiscal 2027 would be in the lower half of the ¥50tn range. The ministry had sought close to ¥80tn to cover new ways of fighting, including drones and AI.
Lawmakers at the meeting objected that the government's figure was “nowhere near enough” amid a severe security environment.
“I cannot accept this. This concerns the very existence of our country. How are they thinking about it?”Taku Otsuka, LDP lower house member
Hiroshi Hamada, who chairs the party's national security research committee, told the meeting that discussion of the three documents would continue, adding that “various information is in fact flying around.”
Neighbors' arsenals and a weak yen
Japan is surrounded by nuclear-armed states. By the latest estimate, China had 20 more nuclear warheads as of January than a year earlier, and North Korea 10 more.
China's defense budget for this fiscal year is about ¥40tn, up 7% from the previous year.
“It is obvious to anyone that the amount currently reported is not enough. And given the exchange rate, the real decline is large.”Masahisa Miyazaki, LDP lower house member
The current plan sets defense spending at ¥43tn over the five years from fiscal 2023. Even at the lower half of the ¥50tn range, the weaker yen would make that a real-terms cut, Miyazaki said.
Cautions on the burden
Some lawmakers want the size of any increase weighed carefully.
“The plan so far is ¥43tn. Finding an extra ¥1tn or ¥2tn a year without asking the public to bear it is about the limit, I think. In the end it falls on the public. We have to discuss properly how far is appropriate.”Takeshi Iwaya, former foreign minister and former defense minister, LDP lower house member
The tug-of-war over defense spending looks set to run toward the end of the year.
