Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Politics
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Ishiba defends tax-cut bill walkout: 'You can't talk about the future if you forget the past'

The former prime minister told a TV program he could not vote for something he did not believe in, and praised Yuko Obuchi, who was also disciplined over the same vote.

By Newsroom1 min read
Ishiba defends tax-cut bill walkout: 'You can't talk about the future if you forget the past'
Former Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, October 29, 2026, Chiyoda Ward, Tokyo. Asahi Shimbun (x)

Former Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said on a TV program that you cannot discuss the future if you forget the past, defending his walkout from the lower house vote on the consumption tax cut and support payment bill, the Asahi Shimbun reported.

Asked why he left the chamber during the vote, the Liberal Democratic Party lawmaker said Diet members answer to the state and the people. "I cannot vote for something I don't even believe in. But because it was decided by the party, I cannot oppose it," he said.

Ishiba said he understood the appeal of lower taxes but could not support the bill without a funding source. "What happens to medical care, pensions and nursing care? The money can't be found, but I'll vote yes — I can't say that," he said.

He pointed to the absence of a clear alternative source of revenue as his chief concern.

A lesson from the consumption tax debut

Ishiba recalled the government of Noboru Takeshita, which introduced Japan's consumption tax. He said the debate ran for dozens of hours with people speaking their minds freely. "We brought in the consumption tax amid painful circumstances," he said.

Some in the party have criticized his stance. "Apparently some people say I should stop talking about the old days, but if you forget the past, how can you talk about the future?" he said, showing his displeasure.

Praise for Obuchi

Yuko Obuchi, a former economy, trade and industry minister, also abstained on the vote and received a reprimand from the party. Ishiba said he has high hopes for her.

"She is a person who does things properly, who doesn't waver this way and that, who really sticks to her principles. That is Yuko Obuchi. I think she is one of the people who will carry Japan from here," he said.