The Nishinippon Shimbun has called on Defense Minister Shinjiro Koizumi to investigate and promptly disclose how the Ground Self-Defense Force's intelligence unit collected personal information on civilians, calling it a serious human rights violation.
The newspaper reported that the unit, the Genti Joho-tai based at Camp Asaka, compiled reports on individuals it contacted and managed them as an organization. The survey items included privacy-sensitive data such as thoughts, beliefs and sexual preferences.
Koizumi told a press conference that "no inappropriate activity has been confirmed" and did not acknowledge that the reports exist. The newspaper said the matter cannot be overlooked from the standpoint of civilian control.
Unit members were assigned countries, mainly in Asia and Africa, and met in Japan with businesspeople from those countries and with Japanese researchers knowledgeable about them. They produced individual reports on each contact, sometimes meeting people while concealing their SDF status.
The surveys covered 41 items, including address, phone number and workplace, along with sensitive details such as beliefs and financial situation. The Act on the Protection of Personal Information prohibits obtaining personal information by improper means.
An expert quoted by the newspaper said the unit collected extremely sensitive information without consent and that this is illegal. The unit is also suspected of deliberately destroying documents bearing a supervisor's seal so they would not be treated as official records subject to disclosure requests.
Reports produced in the course of official duties cannot be called private memos, the newspaper said, and may conflict with the Public Records and Archives Management Act, which requires proper management of administrative documents. It called organized efforts to avoid public scrutiny extremely malicious.
The unit was established in 2007 to gather security information and build contacts needed for UN peacekeeping operations and similar missions. The newspaper said it is hard to find a rationale for collecting personal information on citizens.
Collecting information about people's inner lives without their knowledge could lead to surveillance of citizens critical of the government, the newspaper said, and could threaten freedom of speech and expression.
Before and during the war, the old Japanese military's military police cracked down on thought and speech. The newspaper said it is natural for citizens to feel uneasy when an armed organization gathers information about their inner lives.
Even if thought surveys are not the purpose, doubt remains that stored reports could be used for other ends. Courts have taken up cases involving SDF information-gathering on private citizens.
In a suit by citizens monitored over their opposition to the Iraq deployment, a 2016 Sendai High Court ruling that found the collection of their real names and workplaces illegal was finalized. In 2016 and 2017, the concealment of daily activity reports compiled by a Ground SDF unit on the South Sudan peacekeeping mission became an issue.
The Defense Ministry told a disclosure request that the reports had been discarded, but they were later found to have been kept, and the defense minister at the time resigned to take responsibility.
The newspaper asked whether the ministry has forgotten the lessons of the past. It said what Koizumi must protect is public trust in the SDF, and that he should verify the unit's activities and reports and disclose the findings promptly.