Ruling and opposition parties debated Article 9 at a Lower House constitutional review committee on Thursday, with the LDP pressing to write the Self-Defense Forces into the charter while opposition members questioned whether the change is needed at all.
The Liberal Democratic Party wants to keep paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 9 and add a new "Article 9-2" that explicitly names the Self-Defense Forces. Nippon Ishin no Kai went further, calling for the deletion of paragraph 2, which renounces the holding of war potential, and the creation of a national defense force.
The LDP proposed that the next constitutional review session also take up Article 9. The debate on the clause has spread across a wide range of positions, the Sankei Shimbun reported.
SDF clause at the center
Yoshitaka Shindo, the LDP's lead director on the committee, said the current constitution lacks any provision on national defense. He argued it does not say who defends the country and the people, by what means, or how that force is controlled.
Ishin's Keishi Abe said the Japan-US alliance alone is not enough to counter threats from China, North Korea and Russia. He called for raising ties with Australia, Britain and the Philippines to alliance level, fully approving the right of collective self-defense, and creating a national defense force.
Yuichiro Tamaki of the Democratic Party for the People said the coalition partners envision completely different forms of security. He asked how the principle of exclusively defense-oriented policy would be treated after a revision.
Shindo said only that pacifism would be preserved while allowing what is necessary to defend the country. Abe said the principle of exclusively defense-oriented policy would be kept in spirit but the wording would disappear, and that he has proposed replacing it with "proactive defense." The exchange highlighted the gap between the LDP and Ishin.
Komeito and other parties weigh in
Toru Kunishige, the lead director for the opposition side and a Komeito member, questioned whether the LDP's proposal envisions things that could be achieved through legislation or policy under the current constitution.
Masamune Wada of the Sanseito party called for "constitution-making," or drafting a new charter from scratch. Kimie Hatano of the Japanese Communist Party urged that Article 9 be upheld and the debate on revision halted.
At the previous extraordinary Diet session, an outline of draft wording on an emergency clause for major disasters was presented. Debate on Article 9 remains scattered.
After the session, Kunishige was asked by reporters about drafting text on Article 9. "As a personal view, it is completely impossible," he said.
