Four candidates in the Amagasaki city assembly by-election used posters bearing AI-generated faces that were not their own, and the election commission says election law gives it no power to order them removed, Kansai TV reported.
Voting was held on the 15th in the Hyogo Prefecture city, alongside the mayoral election. The mayor, the incumbent, was returned to office. In the assembly by-election, 12 candidates contested one vacant seat and Hiroko Ikeshita won.
The posters drew attention during the campaign. Residents said the images looked as though they had been made with generative AI. Among them were a man with tattoos on his arm and a portrait in the so-called ikemen style of a handsome older man, each carrying a short message and little else.
One resident told Kansai TV the posters put her off reading them. "I thought it was obviously AI, so I never tried to look closely at what they said."
Commission: the face is not the candidate's
The city election commission said at least four posters may have been produced with generative AI. Asked about the man pictured on the poster of candidate Hiroyoshi Hara, the commission said it recognized the face as not being Hara's own. A commission official acquainted with Hara said the person in the poster was entirely different from him.
The Public Offices Election Act has long left the content of poster photographs largely unregulated. It set requirements for the name of the person responsible and the size of the poster, and nothing more.
That changed in part after the 2024 Tokyo gubernatorial election, where posters showing obscene images of women became an issue. The law was amended to require candidate names to be displayed legibly. It now also bans content that damages another person's reputation or harms public morals.
No provision requires a poster's image to be the candidate's own face. A city official said there is no way to regulate posters that use AI images. "There is freedom of political activity and freedom of expression, so we cannot go as far as ordering the removal of a photograph as inappropriate," the official said.
The same agent filed for all four
The four posters shared a connection. According to the city, former Hyogo Prefectural Assembly member Hikoji Konishi, who has repeatedly run in mayoral elections around the country, or his secretary filed the candidacies on behalf of all four.
The election commission asked Konishi, who filed on their behalf, to come to city hall or submit copies of identification so it could confirm the candidates' faces. Konishi replied that he found the exchange unpleasant, according to the commission.
Residents were unpersuaded. "You don't want people doing strange things like this," one said. Another said the candidates seemed to lack seriousness and were hard to see as sincere.
Reporters walked the streets and telephoned the candidates. They could not meet the candidates themselves or question them.
A printer's line on AI
Kansai TV visited a company that has worked on more than 1,000 elections. Its staff brighten skin tones and remove moles from photographs. Tetsuya Inatsugu demonstrated the removal of a fluorescent light's reflection from a pair of glasses. "The AI inside the app is doing this," he said. "This is how AI should be used."
The company limits AI to image correction and drew up guidelines this month. "AI creates a completely separate face," said May Sano, the company's president. "You get a face utterly unlike the source material. That is not correction at all."
Poster printing is subsidized from public funds, up to about ¥610,000 per candidate in this election. Sano suspects a motive behind the AI use. "If you bill nearly ¥600,000 for posters, make them with AI for next to nothing and pay only the printing costs, the profit is enormous," she said. "Four AI posters among only 12 candidates is suspicious." Social media users have likewise asked whether the public subsidy was the point.
'It's an image'
On the 14th, the final day of campaigning, Kansai TV found the camp of one of the four, candidate Koichi Sato. Sato was absent, and Konishi was giving the speech.
"The posters in Amagasaki have everyone's attention," Konishi told the crowd. "One of the four, numbers 9 to 12, that people say they distrust, is number 12, Koichi Sato. Do you distrust them? I'd like to ask."
He answered questions from Kansai TV after the speech. Asked whether the poster showed Sato himself, Konishi said it was made with AI. Asked whether it was an image rather than a likeness, he said, "An image." Asked whether all four candidates' posters were images, he said, "Images."
On the suggestion that public money was the aim, he said what a contractor does is a matter between the candidate and the contractor. "We comply with the Public Offices Election Act, the commission checks us and has given us the OK," he said. "It is not for people around us to make a fuss."
All four lost, and kept their deposits
All four candidates using AI posters lost. Each won enough votes to have the ¥300,000 deposit required to run returned.
Election consultant Takuma Ohama said the arrangement raises suspicion. "Normally, running for office costs money and ends there," he said. "My suspicion is that this time it ended in profit."
He expects the problem to outrun the statute. "AI may get so good that images appear with no risk of being recognized as AI-made," he said. "The race between technology and the text of the Public Offices Election Act will go on."