Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Crime
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Tokyo court convicts woman over 15 'likes' and reposts of ex-partner's posts

The 30-something defendant was sentenced to six months in prison, suspended for three years, after a prior stalking conviction and a police ban on contacting her former partner.

By Newsroom4 min read

The Tokyo District Court has convicted a woman in her 30s of stalking after she reacted 15 times to her former partner's social media posts, a ruling that treats a "like" as a message to the person who posted it, ABEMA Times reported.

The woman had been told the relationship was over, then kept sending messages on Line. Police issued a ban on stalking and similar conduct in March.

She kept messaging anyway. She was arrested and charged with violating the Stalker Regulation Law, and received a fine.

One week after that ruling, she tapped "like" 14 times on her former partner's posts and reposted one, 15 reactions in all. She was charged again, and the district court handed down six months in prison, suspended for three years.

What the court had to decide

The contested point was whether she reacted to the posts to satisfy romantic feelings toward him. Her defense argued she did not, and sought an acquittal. The court found the feelings were there and convicted her.

Lawyer Ayaka Sakaguchi, speaking on ABEMA Prime, said the ruling treated a like as equivalent to sending a message "rather quickly." She argued the court should first have ruled on whether a like falls under the law's definition of stalking at all.

She said replies, direct messages and messages sent directly to websites were what lawmakers had in mind. "The act of 'liking' was never once discussed while this provision was being drafted," she said.

Sakaguchi raised the principle that a crime must be defined by law before it is punished. "There is a possibility of overreach," she said.

Sun Chenyang, who heads the university admissions database Miraizu, said the law must spell out in advance which acts are criminal. If people hesitate to press like for fear it is a crime and stop using social media, the cost to ordinary users is too great, he said.

Sakaguchi still allowed some room for the court's reading. If a like signals "I am watching you," it is not unreasonable to call that stalking, she said. But liking an ex-partner's post is not automatically stalking, and the ban order was only one factor in the judgment.

For conduct to count as stalking, the target must be made anxious that their safety is at risk, she said. That turns on how the person on the receiving end feels and on any past harassment, which makes such cases hard to judge.

Appeal likely, and the law lags

Sakaguchi expects an appeal. Until the court settles whether a like uses a feature that conveys information, it cannot move on to whether romantic feelings or an intent to unsettle the other person were present, she said.

She also said the law has not kept pace with technology. New tools keep appearing and regulation trails behind, and the law has been amended repeatedly once problems surfaced and no applicable rule existed.

She proposed hearing from people who have committed stalking in advance, to learn how they would try to reach someone on a new social platform, and updating the law before incidents occur.

The people who keep pressing like

Two women who had reacted to ex-partners' posts described the impulse on the program. Suzuka, who kept liking her ex-boyfriend's posts, said she thought she might still have a place in his life and that they might get back together.

"I was immature, so I put my own feelings ahead of his and kept liking," she said. She stopped looking after he found a new partner and she found someone she liked.

Yuko only looked, without liking, so he would not notice. "I was the one who was dumped, so I thought it would bother him and held back," she said. "But I still liked him, and I looked with the hope we might get back together." Yuko is now married and posts about moving on.

Figure skater Miki Ando told Suzuka to think about how the person she cares for feels. Pekopa comedian Tayu Matsuindera said contact used to end when someone could no longer be reached. "The heart shape of the like button is also a problem, because it gives the act meaning," he said.

Sakaguchi warned Suzuka that liking again could make her a criminal. "You do not need to become that for his sake," she said.

Suzuka said being blocked after a breakup is the other person's way of saying they want no contact. "I will hold back from liking," she said. "If you care about someone, you should hold back for their sake too."

Sakaguchi said the Stalker Regulation Law is not meant to resolve tangled romantic disputes, but the habit of chasing the law after incidents happen needs to change.