Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Crime
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Ex-SDF trainee's notes read "I have never once truly laughed" as Gifu shooting trial opens

The first hearing in the Hino firing-range case, which left two SDF members dead, centers on whether Naoto Watanabe was mentally fit to be held responsible.

By Newsroom3 min read
Ex-SDF trainee's notes read "I have never once truly laughed" as Gifu shooting trial opens

The first hearing in the case of a former Self-Defense Forces trainee who opened fire at a Gifu City firing range three years ago, killing two SDF members, opened on the 20th, with the defense arguing he was not mentally fit to be held responsible, CBC TV reported.

Naoto Watanabe, 21, was 18 and an SDF trainee candidate when he fired an automatic rifle at fellow members during live-fire training in June 2023. He took ammunition during the attack, according to the prosecution.

Petty Officer 3rd Class Kosuke Yashiro, 25, and Petty Officer 1st Class Yasuchika Kikumatsu, 52, died. Another male member was seriously injured.

How the shooting unfolded

The range, the Hino Basic Firing Range, is run by the Ground Self-Defense Force. It is a training facility meant to protect the public.

Watanabe loaded a magazine into his rifle at a waiting position where doing so is prohibited. He shot Yashiro as Yashiro tried to stop him, then fired at Kikumatsu and others at the ammunition store.

A former SDF member who once worked alongside Yashiro said both men were kind. "I hope this never happens again," he said in 2024.

Watanabe had placed first among 72 members in shooting training and had been commended for it.

He was 18 at the time, an age classified as a "specified juvenile" under the Juvenile Act. The Gifu District Public Prosecutors Office released his name when it indicted him in February 2024 on robbery-murder and other charges.

Two psychiatric evaluations of his criminal responsibility were carried out, one before and one after indictment. Three years and five months passed between the shooting and the first hearing.

Watanabe appeared in court in a sweatshirt, opening his mouth wide in what looked like a yawn. Asked by the presiding judge whether he had anything to say about the charges, he replied, "Nothing in particular."

Notes in his pocket

The defense did not dispute the facts but argued for acquittal, saying he was not in a mental state in which he could be held criminally responsible.

Prosecutors said a note showing planning was found in Watanabe's pocket at the time of the attack. It listed the number and positions of the members in charge of ammunition, along with these lines:

  • "In 18 years of life, I am the most excited I have ever been."
  • "There has never been a single time in my life when I truly laughed."
  • "Equal death is the only thing in the world. I will fix this country."

Watanabe had a strong interest in guns and war and was advancing procedures to travel to Ukraine to join the fighting. Before the attack, he told a superior he wanted to shoot people on a battlefield.

Citing that conduct, prosecutors argued he had no mental disorder at the time and could be held fully responsible.

The defense said signs of schizophrenia had appeared when Watanabe was in his third year of high school. There was "no room for normal mental function to operate," it argued.

Support group says little has changed

A woman with an NPO that corresponded with Watanabe in place of his family said he was immature to begin with. Three years on, detention had given him no environment in which to change.

“I think he has barely changed since the time of the incident.”Kyoko Abe, head of the NPO World Open Heart

The verdict is scheduled to be handed down in February.