Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Crime
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Ex-Jungle Pocket member Saito sentenced to 4 years over power imbalance

The Tokyo District Court found the comedian's standing over a co-star left her unable to refuse, in a test of Japan's revised consent law.

By Newsroom1 min read
Ex-Jungle Pocket member Saito sentenced to 4 years over power imbalance
Defendant Shinji Saito in Suginami Ward, Tokyo, on December 26, 2021. (x)

The Tokyo District Court sentenced former Jungle Pocket member Shinji Saito, 44, to four years in prison on the 16th for nonconsensual sexual intercourse and other charges, a ruling that turned on the power imbalance between the comedian and a woman who appeared with him on a TV program.

Presiding Judge Yuko Ito handed down the sentence, which the prosecution had sought at seven years. Saito had argued for full acquittal.

The Mainichi Shimbun reported that the court found the gap in standing between Saito and the woman, a co-star on the program, led to the prison term.

A defense built on equal footing

Saito told a June court session, when defendants are questioned, that no gap in standing existed between him and the woman.

“Whether my years in the business or my name recognition is above hers has nothing to do with it.”Shinji Saito, defendant

He consistently rejected the prosecution's account that the woman could not refuse because she feared resisting would hurt her future work.

Cases in which a person cannot express a lack of consent out of concern about disadvantages from another's influence, based on economic or social position, are known as sexual abuse that exploits a gap in standing.

The revised Penal Code that took effect in July 2023 made such cases subject to the crimes of nonconsensual sexual intercourse and nonconsensual indecent assault.

Saito's defense argued that for a sexual crime exploiting a gap in standing to be recognized, the perpetrator must objectively be able to exercise influence. The defense said Saito had no authority over casting and therefore lacked that objective influence.

The woman countered in court that Saito held major influence with the production side. If he said she should not be used, she testified, she thought her work would dry up.