Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Crime
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

A third of a fingerprint: how Okayama police caught a killer 40 days before the statute ran out

Advances in fingerprint matching and restoration let investigators identify a suspect 15 years after a 55-year-old woman was robbed and strangled in her Okayama apartment.

By Newsroom4 min read
A third of a fingerprint: how Okayama police caught a killer 40 days before the statute ran out
The apartment where the fugitive lived (photographed in 1990) (x)

A partial fingerprint — about a third of a fingertip — left on a bank withdrawal slip helped Okayama police arrest a woman's killer 40 days before the statute of limitations expired, Daily Shincho reported, as advances in fingerprint matching reopened a case that the 15-year limit was about to close for good.

On December 26, 1975, a 55-year-old woman was robbed and murdered in an apartment in Okayama. Prefectural police mounted a large investigation but lost the killer's trail in the first days.

The statute of limitations then stood at 15 years, before revisions to the Code of Criminal Procedure. Police made the arrest on November 16, 1990.

A shrinking investigation

A newspaper reporter assigned to the prefectural police, involved in the case from the start, told the magazine that more than 6,000 people were listed in investigation headquarters records. Witnesses kept surfacing and fading, but that stopped around 1979.

Investigators focused on small-business people in Osaka with ties to Okayama. The killer had been overheard in a taxi saying business in Osaka was bad and small firms could not pay decent wages.

In October 1979, two people emerged as candidates. Both had alibis, and that line of inquiry closed.

In 1980 the task force was cut from 80 officers to seven, then to three. Those three worked other cases as they arose.

The withdrawal slip

The breakthrough came from a fingerprint. When the killer withdrew ¥2.6 million from Chugoku Bank, he left on the withdrawal request form a print covering about a third of a fingertip, apparently from the middle finger of his left hand.

Police compared it with prints from 7,000 people with criminal records. It matched a suspect arrested by Shiga prefectural police in 1976 on suspicion of car theft.

Hiroshi Morishita, 64, who headed the prefectural police's investigation section when the murder occurred, said fingerprint work had been a priority from the start, with checks run by the prefectural force and the National Police Agency.

“There was no technology to restore a whole print, and no computer matching. And at the time of the murder, the July 1976 car theft had not happened yet.”Hiroshi Morishita, former head of the Okayama prefectural police investigation section

Fingerprint work continued in the years that followed, but the technology of the time could not identify the killer, he said.

Fifteen years of better technology

Fingerprint identification was overhauled around 1971, when semi-automated matching was introduced. Computers could not yet recognize patterns, so examiners converted fingerprint features into numerical values and entered them by hand.

About a decade of research produced an automatic reader that let computers recognize patterns and store prints as images, said Tatsuya Suzuki, a former head of the Chugoku regional police bureau.

Fingerprint examination now sits in its own center, separate from the identification division, and the National Police Agency holds prints from 6 million people arrested in the past, Suzuki said.

Crime-scene prints rarely show clean ridges. Whorls and the start, end and crossing of lines are often unclear, so examiners reasonably infer what features the invisible parts must have held. Okayama prefectural police did that restoration work in this case.

The veteran reporter questioned the timing, telling the magazine the arrest could have come five years earlier. "It feels less like he happened to be caught in the statute-of-limitations year than like he was caught because this was the year the statute ran out," he said.

A newspaper dealer in Kobe

The suspect was from Kyushu. He dropped out of high school, worked locally for a time, then moved to Kobe. His mother in his hometown told the magazine the family heard almost nothing from him after that.

In Kobe he worked at a newspaper delivery outlet and became a supervisor around the time he married. From 1974 he ran an Asahi Shimbun dealership in the Fukae district, where neighbors described him as earnest and kind.

Police concluded the strain of running the dealership drove the crime. Some accounts also pointed to a fondness for gambling.

He divorced his wife and children in 1978 and moved to Tokyo, working at several real estate firms in Tokyo and Chiba before joining a company in 1986. There he earned ¥18 million a year and was tipped for a board post.

Morishita was at work when the prefectural investigation section chief called at 3 p.m. on November 16. He kept his delight to himself while colleagues wondered at his grin, then slipped outside to a pay phone to tell his wife.

“She said "thank goodness, thank goodness" over and over.”Hiroshi Morishita, former head of the Okayama prefectural police investigation section

The suspect initially refused to talk, then confessed fully. Posing as a salesman, he had realized the woman was the wife of an executive, struck her with an ashtray and strangled her. He was in debt of about ¥15 million at the time, mostly from gambling.

He was charged with robbery and murder and received a 15-year prison term at trial the following year.