Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Crime
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Nagoya court orders former sixth-grader to pay ¥400,000 over classmate's personal data

The ruling found the child, then 12 or so, old enough to bear liability for posting a classmate's name and school online — a standard lawyers say hinges on age and schooling, not a fixed number.

By Newsroom2 min read
Nagoya court orders former sixth-grader to pay ¥400,000 over classmate's personal data
An elementary school girl using a smartphone (stock photo) (x)

The Nagoya District Court has ordered a child who was then a sixth-grader to pay ¥400,000 for posting a classmate's name and school on an online forum, a ruling that puts the question of children's legal liability online to parents, Lawyer Dotcom News reported.

The suit was brought by a girl in Nagoya. She said her name and school had been written on the forum, invading her privacy, and sought damages from the classmate and the classmate's parents.

The ruling is dated October 15. The classmate's side has appealed, according to Kyodo News.

The girl, then in the sixth grade, posted on the forum in spring last year under a display name matching her first name. The classmate entered her name and school as the user information behind that display name.

When a child can be held liable

Children bear damages liability only if they have the capacity to understand the consequences of their acts. Article 712 of the Civil Code excuses a minor who "lacks the intelligence to discern the responsibility for his or her own acts."

The law sets no age threshold. Past court rulings have generally used around 12 as a guide, with the child's development and living environment weighed case by case.

The court found the child responsible, reasoning that schools can be assumed to teach pupils how to handle personal information properly, the report said. Age and classroom guidance appear to have convinced the court the child understood what posting someone's details online meant.

Why a name and a school

The girl had used only her first name as a display name. Once her full name and school were attached, anyone reading the forum could work out who she was in real life.

Linking an online identity to a person's real-life identity is generally something people do not want others to know. The court treated the disclosure against her will as an invasion of privacy.

The girl's lawyer, Yohei Shimizu, said the ruling turns on privacy rather than on insults. He advises parents to explain, with concrete examples, which posts can infringe someone's rights and lead to damages.

Writing a friend's name or school, or posting a photo without permission, is a problem even without name-calling, he said. Anonymous posts can still be traced to their author.

He recommends that parents set rules for smartphone use together with their child and turn on filtering.

What parents owe

If the ruling stands, the payment obligation falls on the child named in it, not the parents. In practice, parents often cover the sum when a child has no money.

Parents can still be held liable under Article 714 of the Civil Code if they neglected their duty to supervise the child. The neglected supervision must also be shown to have caused the damage.