The Chiba District Court has voided a one-day suspension given to a male employee who clocked in and out for a female colleague he was shielding from a manager's sexual harassment, finding he acted to prevent further abuse, Kyodo News reported.
The man worked at a Honda Mobility Minami-Kanto car dealership in Chiba. He sued the company to have the disciplinary action withdrawn.
Presiding Judge Shusaku Tatara accepted the woman's account, finding it consistent. A manager at a restaurant had kissed her and committed other acts of sexual harassment, the court found.
Punching the clock for another employee does constitute grounds for discipline, the judge said. But the man was trying to keep the manager away from the woman, and "the purpose was to prevent further harassment," Tatara found.
Company denied harassment occurred
The company argued that no harassment took place. Even if it had, that would not justify clocking in on someone else's behalf, it told the court.
According to the ruling, the man clocked in for the woman 20 to 30 times between 2021 and 2022. The company suspended him for one day in August 2022.
The man's lawyer said the decision carries "extremely important significance." The court voided the punishment by weighing the motive of protecting a harassment victim, even though the man had breached workplace rules on the surface, the lawyer said.
