Tokyo DispatchWhat'sOnNow
Business
Tokyo DispatchJapan, in English

Amazon delivery driver's contract ended by notice, exposing 'freelance in name only'

A driver in western Japan learned his work would dry up through a notice sent between companies, not to him. Labor experts say such workers are employees in all but title.

By Newsroom4 min read

A delivery driver in his 30s who carries Amazon parcels as an independent contractor was told his work would end through a contract termination notice sent between companies, the Nishinippon Shimbun reported, in a case highlighting Japan's "freelance in name only" problem.

The practice refers to workers who hold business-entrustment contracts but work under a company's direction like regular employees. Under labor law, they should be protected as workers. In name, they are sole proprietors.

In late October, the man, who works in western Japan, learned of the notice. A week earlier, Amazon's prime contractor sent a contract termination notice to the shipping company he holds his contract with.

The notice said the number of vehicles scheduled to operate would be cut from November. The contract would end at the close of January next year.

The man began delivery work about four years ago after returning to his hometown, having worked at restaurants in Fukuoka Prefecture after high school. He now delivers about 25 days a month.

He sometimes takes another part-time job at night, but delivery pay is his main income. On workdays he checks the delivery addresses and routes sent to a dedicated smartphone app each morning.

He loads parcels into a leased light van and drives from the depot to his delivery stops. Following the app, he visits about 200 addresses a day on average.

Deliveries once took him so long that he was often late for appointed times. When work ran past midnight, his daily pay stayed the same. He had no compensation for days off sick.

He had no discretion over delivery addresses or routes. The notice arrived after he had worked this way. His own work was not the problem; a change in the contract between the companies threatened to leave him without work.

“Drivers have lives riding on this. I've worked seriously, and I don't want to lose my place.”the driver, Amazon delivery contractor

The shipping company said the prime contractor indicated in later negotiations that drivers could keep working as before from February. Specific terms and who is covered remain unclear, and the effect on about 60 drivers is hard to foresee.

“The explanations keep changing, and my distrust is growing.”the driver

The prime contractor said it could not answer any questions from the press. Amazon Japan said it was not in a position to comment on matters between other companies.

"As a basic policy, we work to ensure drivers can work in a fair and safe environment," Amazon Japan said.

Labor law and the reality of the job

According to the health ministry, a sole proprietor can still be covered by labor law if the actual working arrangement is judged that of an employee. A 1985 study group report is used as a reference for that judgment.

The criteria include whether the person can choose whether to accept work requests and instructions, whether the employer gives orders, and whether working place and hours are constrained. Meeting them makes the person a worker under the Labor Standards Act.

In practice, freelancers who object to their treatment are often refused, leaving them to seek relief from a labor commission or file suit. Such cases are constant.

Tatsuya Sekiguchi, 61, secretary-general of the Tokyo-based National Union of General Workers and a supporter of Amazon drivers, said objecting can cost a driver the contract. Lawsuits take time, so many end up unable to speak out, he said.

Drivers have their shifts managed and receive app instructions on where and how many parcels to deliver, according to Sekiguchi. They pay their own vehicle upkeep and fuel.

Because they are not employees, they get no premium pay for late-night or holiday work and no paid leave. Companies also avoid bearing their social insurance costs.

Freelance workers have grown in number. Gig work has spread through app-based food delivery and short-term job matching. Sekiguchi said Japan needs to think about rules that protect these new workers.

Calls for a legal presumption of employment

Shigeru Wakita, an emeritus professor of labor law at Ryukoku University, points to a 2006 International Labour Organization recommendation. It tells member states to judge worker status by the facts of the job, whatever the contract is called.

The recommendation also calls for rejecting disguised self-employment, in which a business-owner format is used to escape labor protections. Overseas court rulings and European Union rules increasingly treat indirect management through apps as real direction and classify such workers as employees, Wakita said.

Wakita said Japan must adopt a presumption of employment. Under it, a worker would be treated as an employee in a dispute unless the employer can prove otherwise.

“Internationally, Japan's measures for freelancers are a lap behind. We should shift to active policies that respond to global trends.”Shigeru Wakita, emeritus professor of labor law, Ryukoku University